A group for GamesBeat writer, readers, and more

Why Microsoft shouldn’t lay off so many Xbox employees | The DeanBeat

Microsoft is expected to lay off a lot of employees on July 6. We don’t have full transparency into the numbers yet, and we probably won’t even hear that or the full circumstances behind the layoffs even after Monday.

The game industry is pretty dark these days when it comes to transparency, but Microsoft signaled the layoffs are coming and the {LINK REMOVED}CWA union spoke up about how it should handle it. I interviewed some of those {LINK REMOVED}Xbox workers. Having looked at those sides and talked to others who understand the business, I think there are plenty of reasons for the company to hold back.

The situation is fluid. We hear there are five studios set for closure, or could be saved from closure by a sale: Arkane (Marvel Blade, Dishonored), Double Fine (Kiln, Keeper), Undead Labs (State of Decay 3), Compulsion Games (South of Midnight) and Ninja Theory (Senua). On top of that, there are expected to be percentage cuts across other studios. (Obsidian is not one set for closure, as feared).

On LinkedIn, {LINK REMOVED}Amir Satvat has posted an upcoming session on how Xbox folks can try to find jobs. Based on talking to finance sources, I believe that there is interest in at least some of the studios that Microsoft wants to unload. The big question, of course, is the price and how long it will take to get deals done.

Overall, Microsoft has around 40 studios with more than 20,000 employees. To those who say Microsoft should cut the fat, it has already laid off more than 5,000 Xbox people across four layoffs in recent years.

Even without these new studios targeted for shutdown, it will still have a huge business, as none of these are in the top 10. In her first hundred days, Xbox CEO Asha Sharma took decisive action on matters like getting rid of an unpopular ad campaign (“This is an Xbox”), cutting subscription prices and taking Call of Duty out of it, and keeping more exclusives for the the dedicated Xbox fans. But she saw a need to address bigger problems. Those problems are very difficult to solve, as noted by former {LINK REMOVED}Nexon CEO Owen Mahoney in this essay.

[img]{LINK REMOVED}https://gamesbeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Asha-Sharma-and-Matt-Booty-1024x682.jpg[/img] Asha Sharma and Matt Booty. Credit: Xbox Without the financial transparency, it’s hard to fathom why the Xbox team believes it’s in a financial crisis, considering Microsoft can afford it. It is the fourth most valuable company in the world, with a valuation of $2.9 trillion.

The company generates hundreds of billions of dollars in revenue any given year, with Xbox accounting for maybe a tenth of that. This year, revenues for the fiscal year are expected to hit $327 billion, up from $280 billion a year ago. It has its Azure enterprise and AI business as its crown jewel, not to mention steady sales of Windows, Office, LinkedIn and more.

In the short term, Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said the company has been supporting Xbox through good and bad years for 25 years, but he believes it should be “sustainable.”

Facing seven big “realities,” Xbox CEO Asha Sharma and No. 2 Matt Booty pointed out they needed to “{LINK REMOVED}reset” the games business. They noted they have strong franchises, but they are in competition for attention with not only games from the likes of Sony and Nintendo but also other forms of entertainment and more. They will end the fiscal year with a 3% accountability margin, down from a year ago.

Excluding Activision Blizzard King (acquired for $68.7 billion), they said they spent over $25 billion on ongoing investments in games as well as a hardware subsidy, but annual revenue has declined half a billion during that time. They said “going forward, this cannot continue,” but didn’t say why. They said they needed the pipeline of content to meet goals on subscription, streaming and devices, but they are now overextended. Now they have to reassess that investment for the next five years.

The Xbox leaders also said memory chip prices are five times higher than two years ago, affecting not only the profits of current hardware but also the prospects for the upcoming Project Helilx console. They said it’s taking too long to get games done given Microsoft’s own legacy systems and it has offloaded too many tasks to outsiders.

They didn’t mention that the Xbox Series X/S has been in a distant third place, selling 35 million or so consoles since 2019 compared to 93 million for the Sony PlayStation 5 and 175 million for the Nintendo Switch and Switch 2 combined. Steam is also making headway with perhaps five million Steam Decks sold, not to mention its just launched Steam Machines.

For sure, Microsoft should continue to be careful with spending and make sure it provides the supervision across the portfolio of studios to ensure that spending and schedules aren’t out of control. Yet, again, it has already had multiple Xbox layoffs.

One of the big reasons for viewing this in a negative way is that Microsoft leaders probably expected better results from strategies that haven’t panned out yet, like the Xbox Game Pass subscription, which had to face a price cut and pull Call of Duty out of the base subscription. The results for cloud gaming and mobile games also haven’t moved the needle. At the same time, Microsoft has had to raise engineering costs to get Project Helix ready, and it has even taken the unheard of step (like Sony and Nintendo in the tariff era) of raising hardware prices, most recently by up to $150 — the third time it has done so.

Is there bloat at Xbox? It is quite possible.

One game maker I interviewed fretted that one of the problems at Xbox was that different marching orders came from different leadership departments at Xbox. One party wanted games to boost subscription revenues for Xbox Game Pass and to boost hours spent playing games in Game Pass. Another goal from finance was additional profit and revenue. Still others simply wanted Microsoft first party studios to show that the company’s tech platform was a good place to publish games, while another favored push platforms. Since each of these goals led to different portfolio decisions, studios grew in size due to trying to fulfill the ambiguous goals. But studio heads function best when the goals are crystal clear.

[img]{LINK REMOVED}https://gamesbeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/MW4_CAM_013_BRANDED-1024x576.jpg[/img] A South Korean soldier in the maelstrom of Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4. Source: Infinity Ward/Activision For sure, AI is Microsoft’s cash cow. But it’s a cash cow without a soul, competing other cash cows of OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and Meta. By comparison, Xbox has the dedicated fan base of gaming, and gamers are engaged like no other form of fandom. It is the way that Microsoft truly reaches the hearts of consumers, not through necessities like Windows, Office or even CoPilot. The layoffs are causing damage to the long-term Xbox brand in the eyes of gamers, who are the underappreciated assets of Xbox.

Much of this worry is founded in short-term thinking and temporary circumstances. Microsoft has plenty of huge franchises to support its “tentpole” strategy, where the major hits raise the tent so high that there is plenty of room to support smaller experimental games.

The best game studios take multiple years to cook games properly, as they’re not like other kinds of products as there is so much artistic work involved. Games also need to be vetted with players to see if they’re on the right track, and they have to be revised regularly in response to feedback.

So even the best studios aren’t able to produce a solid game every single year to please financial analysts. By their very nature, games require patient capital and trust in teams. Game developers need a stable environment where they can be creative and shoot for the moon, which is necessary when 20,000 games come out a year on Steam alone.

I spoke with Morgan Goin, a senior encounter designer at ZeniMax Online and a CWA union rep, in an interview about the layoffs and AI’s role.

“I hate having to go to career days and say, “Here’s what my career was. I was here for this long and then I got laid off. I was there for this long and then I got laid off.” I hate having to have the conversation and say, ‘Look, if you want to get into this industry, you’d better have a spouse with a consistent job, because that’s the only way I made it.’ I hate having to see the looks on kids’ faces. I don’t want to do that anymore,” said Goin.

The smaller games can often lose money and generate too little revenue, but they are often key to providing new original intellectual property, which is critical to the future in establishing new franchises that can offset the decline of aging ones. Any company with the strategy of investing only in its current hits is doomed to a long decline.

You can expect that AI will change much of the picture for game development, with improvements in productivity that could speed creation and lead to permanent reductions in team size. But few believe that time is already here.

“I’m happy to use the tools. I experiment with the tools that exist now,” said Allison Veneto, a senior editor for franchise development at Blizzard, said in an interview with me. “If it makes my job easier, I’m not against using them. But it’s a question of letting the workers have some agency over the decision about how they use it in their job.”

In its previous quarterly report, Microsoft said revenues for Xbox were down 7%, but it also noted it was setting records for monthly active users. It foresaw a revenue decline in content and services in the low teens.

Activision had a weak year with Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 year, as it faced serious competition from Battlefield 6 and the brand-new franchise ARC Raiders. It won’t face the same competition this year on that front, and this year’s Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 4 is expected to be a much better game coming from the Infinity Ward studio as the lead. Call of Duty needs sustained investment as it takes around 3,000 or more people a year to make annual games. And this year, Activision is adding Call of Duty to the Nintendo Switch 2 platform.

For sure, Call of Duty will face serious competition this year from Grand Theft Auto VI, a game that has been in the works at Rockstar for around 13 years or so. It debuts like a juggernaut on November 19, 2026, and almost no other games are competing with it that month. But Microsoft gets a share of that business, as it will be published on Xbox platforms. Such a third-party game could lift Microsoft’s sales this year in the critical holiday season.

There are levers Microsoft can pull to lower hardware costs and improve its reach with games. It could pull out optical drives from the system and get rid of physical distribution of disks. The disks have been a source of piracy and used resales that generate no money for game makers or Microsoft. And the drives add cost and bulk to the game consoles.

Of course, many gamers still get their games in a physical format, and they love it. Sony’s own move in this direction has triggered a backlash from fans. So this move could be damaging, but the point is to show players that they can get to a lower price for their hardware with this sacrifice.

[img]{LINK REMOVED}https://gamesbeat.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/halo-sword-1024x576.jpg[/img] Master Chief is back. Source: Microsoft For sure, Xbox should invest in its core franchises, and it’s doing so in spite of these layoffs.

On the side of improving reach, it could launch a cloud-based gaming solution with little physical hardware (bypassing the expensive memory costs). This could be an ad-supported service with a low subscription price that could work with games hosted in the cloud and displayed only on connected TVs — which number more than a billion now. Hardcore gamers haven’t opted for this kind of service yet, but faced with $1,000-plus consoles, they might now.

If that isn’t appealing enough on the cost front, Microsoft could also launch a hardware device in the $300 price range — a price that many more households can afford — or it could acquire Nex, maker of the motion-sensing console Nex Playground. This is the gaming for the people approach, rather than appealing to hardcore gamers with cool but expensive hardware.

Microsoft could also make a bigger push into mobile games and set up a better direct-to-consumer store to capture margins. Most children are getting their start with games on phones now. It could also turn its cash cow Minecraft into a game platform that is more like the user-generated content platforms of Roblox and Fortnite — where the kids are congregating. Netflix is among the companies investing heavily in games played on TVs with remote controls or smartphones. Some kind of hybrid of the smartphone with other platforms seems like it could reach more people who aren’t players now.

For sure, Microsoft could spread its forces into the rest of the world and hire {LINK REMOVED}low-cost game developers and outsourcing companies.

It can operate studios more inexpensively with remote work — something its unions have been asking for — and yet that doesn’t mean that the veterans in high-cost areas are disposable.

The CWA union workers I interviewed made the case for understanding how worker morale and inspiration matter. {LINK REMOVED}Phil Spencer, Microsoft’s previous Xbox CEO, pointed to how Double Fine’s creativity inspires other game developers to take risks. This was in a day when there wasn’t some kind of Xbox emergency — other than the failed will of the highest executives. It’s worth nothing that while Sony is laying off 300 at Bungie and Electronic Arts has laid off staff as well, Nintendo hasn’t laid off staff, and a few years ago it gave employees 10% raises.

Lastly, as I’ve said many times, games can rise from subculture to mass culture, and in doing so win the attention war against the addiction industries like gambling, social media, social video, AI companions, prediction markets and porn. Games can do this by staying squarely in the realm of fun, and moving into other entertainment like YouTube, TikTok, movies, TV shows and more. Like with the game of civilization, games can win the culture war.

The post {LINK REMOVED}Why Microsoft shouldn’t lay off so many Xbox employees | The DeanBeat appeared first on {LINK REMOVED}GamesBeat.